Skip to Content

18 Best Restaurants In Sebastian, Florida

18 Best Restaurants In Sebastian, Florida

When you wander through the inviting town of Sebastian, perched on the east coast of Florida, your taste buds are in for as much of an adventure as your spirit! Here’s my handpicked guide to the 18 best restaurants in Sebastian, where the locals love to loiter, and the food is worth penning a postcard about.

best-restaurants-in-sebastian-florida-shrimp-tacos-with-fries

The family-friendly town of Sebastian is between Palm Bay and Vero Beach, with quality lodging, abundant outdoor attractions, and, as mentioned, tasty restaurants. You can plan a vacation on your own or even rent a car to get there. 

kayaking-in-sebastian-inlet

1. Blackfins (Captain Hiram’s Resort)

Join the locals at the heart of Sebastian’s riverfront charm, affectionately known as Hiram’s but officially Blackfins Riverfront Grill. It’s the town’s go-to for your morning breakfast, a leisurely lunch, or dinner delights, especially if fresh seafood is your calling.

blackfins-fried-shrimp-and-scallops

Sip on tropical concoctions so picturesque they beg a snapshot. And when in Florida, you can’t miss what’s been hailed as the best Peel n’ Eat Shrimp—addictive flavor at unbeatable value. It’s the butter, trust me, that sets this restaurant above all the rest.

captain-hirams-crab-dip

Try the Cobb Salad, tantalizing tacos, or the crave-worthy Crab and Artichoke Dip for a quick pick or sumptuous meal. Burger or Fish & Chips fans, look no further. Pair your feast with daily live tunes and panoramic Indian River views. And if you’re lucky, catch a comical pelican show as boaters offload their catch. They love to hang around Hiram’s and get scraps from the fishermen.

blackfins-at-capt-hirams

2. Capt ‘n Butcher’s

Discover an enchanting dining gem nestled along Indian River Drive, Capt’ n Butcher’s. This seaside haven offers patrons the choice to revel in the stunning riverside panorama, soaking up Sebastian’s serene vibe from the comfort of the bar, cozy indoor seating, or the breezy outdoor terrace. Expert bartenders craft a symphony of delightful libations sure to tantalize your taste buds.

I ordered the crispy Fried Shrimp Basket, accompanied by heavenly cheese grits and a classic, tangy coleslaw – a divine pairing indeed.

On the other hand, my daughter chose the robust flavors of the Grouper Tacos, accompanied by a generous helping of golden fries. And if you’ve saved just a sliver of space for dessert, the Key Lime Pie is a slice of Floridian bliss not to be missed. Remember to swing by during happy hour for some unbeatable deals!

For those searching for the best restaurants in Sebastian, Capt’ n Butcher’s stands out as a must-visit spot where palatable pleasures meet southern hospitality.

fried-shrimp-plate-with-grits

3. Country Ham N Egg Restaurant

Right off the main road, the Country Ham N Egg is a local’s favorite Sebastian eatery. This cozy spot offers classic breakfasts done right, and for lunch, the plates are brimming with homestyle comfort – think Philly Cheesesteaks and Chicken Parm Sandwiches that promise a return visit.

My favorite are the classic breakfasts with excellent omelets and breakfast meats.

ham-and-egg-with-breakfast-potatoes
Photo from Country Egg n Ham’s FB page.

4. Crab E. Bills

The moment you step into Crab E Bills, you can’t help but feel a sea breeze of authenticity. They aptly say, ‘If it were any fresher, it would still be swimming,’ and they mean it! From succulent wild-caught shrimp to the freshest oysters, your seafood dreams are impeccably catered to.

And those garlic crab legs? To die for.

5. Crab Stop

Are you craving snow crab legs? Sebastian’s Crab Stop has you covered! Not only do they serve up a rave-worthy Snow Special — a generous combo of crab, jumbo shrimp, potatoes, and corn that’s ideal for sharing — but their homemade seafood plates, served up on a vibrant patio to the tune of live music, really hit the spot in a laid-back atmosphere.

For those wanting a unique dish, try the Caribbean Seafood rice (sautéed mixed vegetables, crab meat, shrimp, sausage, and pineapple) served in a quartered pineapple.

caribbean-seafood-rice-crab-stop

6. Earl’s Hideaway

Tucked away from the bustle, Earl’s Hideaway Lounge has an old Florida charm that feels timeless and lively. Grab their slow-cooked BBQ while listening to live bands that set the scene for a nostalgic escapade. Here, every bite feels like a piece of local history.

My daughter swears they have the best pizza in town.

earls-hideaway

7. Hen House Eatery

For breakfast lovers, Hen House Eatery rules the roost in Sebastian. This spot dazzles with dishes from pancake stacks to luscious crepes. I indulged in the Veggie Crepe and loved the fresh, savory filling. I can’t wait to feast again. And take it from me, their Monte Cristo is the real deal—perfectly paired with raspberry preserves.

hen-house-eatery-monte-cristo

8. Marsh Landing

Though technically in Fellsmere, Marsh Landing, an iconic Florida eatery, should be on your radar. 

A short drive to Fellsmere brings you to Marsh Landing — an honorary member of Sebastian’s dining scene. Picture a rustic setting that serves up history alongside heaping portions of frog legs and catfish.

My favorite things at Marsh Landing are the breakfast Benedicts (like the Marsh, with fried green tomatoes and bacon!), Sweet Potato Pancakes, and the Gigger omelet with corned beef hash and cream cheese. And by all means, try the epic pimento cheese grilled biscuits served with bacon jam. It’s a home run!

marsh-landing-shrimp-skewers

9. Mo-Bay Grille

Step into the vibrant atmosphere of Mo-Bay Grill, Sebastian’s treasure, where the decor is as sunny as our skies. Ranked at the pinnacle of the best restaurants in the area, Mo-Bay Grill entices you with a blend of American and Jamaican flavors, setting your taste buds on a mouthwatering adventure from dawn to dusk.

Kickstart your morning with the Banana Nut Bread French Toast, a twist that sings, or the Corned Beef Hash Benedict, a savory delight. Come afternoon, savor a bite of the Caribbean with our zesty Conch Fritters, relish the freshness of our Salmon Tostada Salad, or indulge in the Jerk Chicken Pasta – a hearty dish with a sauce that dances on the palate.

pasta-dish-from-mo-bay-grill-best-restaurants-sebastian

10. Mulligan’s Beach House

Mulligan’s Beach House in Sebastian is a gem along the Treasure Coast, stealing my heart among its seven siblings. For breakfast, indulge in their Spinach Benedict—a heavenly swap for Canadian Bacon with luscious parmesan spinach dip. And their roasted potatoes? Simply the best sidekick to morning meals.

mulligans-omelet-and-toast

When it’s time for lunch, give me the Southwest Burger—cajun-spiced, dripping with jack cheese, and topped with fiery jalapeños, nestled on crisp lettuce and veggies. No fries are needed when their green beans reign supreme!

Come dinner, feast on anything from hearty Nachos to luxurious Lobster Rolls or the tropical zing of an Island Grouper with pineapple salsa. And if cocktails are calling, answer with Mulligan’s impeccable Bloody Marys—the toast of the town.

mulligans-beach-house-spinach-benedict

11. Old Fish House

About 20 minutes from Sebastian, in Grant-Valkaria lies The Old Fish House, a really great restaurant well worth the drive. It sits on the Indian River Lagoon off Hwy 1 and offers line-to-plate seafood dishes.

This “five star dive bar” boasts succulent shrimp, smoked fish dip, fire-roasted mussels, and the best conch fritters around, served with banana pepper rings and chipotle sauce. Seafood isn’t the only thing on the menu…I’m crazy about the black bean soup and Cubano sandwich.

the-old-fish-house-shrimp

12. Pareidolia Brewing Company

Pareidolia Brewing Company is not just a brewery; it’s a homestead of hoppy happiness, complete with a fun and funky vibe. With scenic river views and live music that hugs your soul, this spot is perfect for unwinding. I’m all about their award-winning craft beers, but their mouth-watering pub-style eats, like flatbreads and “big” hot dogs, make the whole experience a culinary crescendo.

Whatever you do, try the PBC poutine with stout-infused brown gravy and scallions —it’s incredible. Pareidolia is closed on Mondays.

pareidolia-brewing-co

13. Pelican Diner

At Sebastian’s Pelican Diner, relish tranquil breakfasts and lunches kissed by golf course and airport views. Their biscuits bathed in gravy offer a comforting start, but the Greek Omelette with generous hash browns will not disappoint the adventurous foodie. 

Cherished memories and flavors await at its new location, just as beloved as the old.

pelican-diner-omelet-and-hash-browns

14. Sandy’s Grille

Take advantage of Sandy’s Grille, a hidden gem known for its hearty sandwiches and crowd-pleasing Loaded Tater Tots. With options like Garlic Parmesan Wings and the Black & Blue Burger, your taste buds will thank you. 

And if you’ve got kids, they’re flexible enough to whip up something they’ll love, even without a kid’s menu.

outside-sandys-grille-sebastian

15. Squid Lips

Squid Lips boasts a relaxed atmosphere that’s hard to beat, with a view that’s as splendid as its food. Enjoy the fun and funky waterside seating and savor starters like the queso dip with trim-colored tortilla chips. The wings are epic, too.

Squid Lips’ menu includes delicious dishes like blackened fish tacos, Cuban sandwiches, and pasta dishes. Or, if seafood is more your style, the raw bar with mussels, clams, shrimp, and oysters delivers a powerful punch. Wash it down with your favorite adult libations on happy hour weekdays from 3 to 7 PM.

squid-lips-wings

16. Vic’s Pizza

Vic’s Pizza is your go-to for those Italian cravings. Choose from hand-tossed thin-crust pizza to Sicilian, or double up with the Double Decker. Savor the simplicity of their ham calzone oozing with ricotta and mozzarella, or dig into classics like spaghetti & meatballs and eggplant parmesan.

Hungry for variety? They’ve got seafood, burgers, subs, and salads, too.

vics-pizza-garlic-knots

17. Village Tavern

The Village Tavern is your cozy sports bar escape tucked away in Sebastian’s Village Square. The welcoming staff greets you like family, and yes, toddlers, too! Complimentary popcorn, daily specials, and soul-satisfying eats await. Try the stellar Chicken Quesadilla or signature Pepperoni Pinwheels.

Enjoy standout flavors and unwind during happy hour from 4-6 PM on weekdays.

village-tavern-sebastian

18. Wasabi Thai Sushi

Nestled in the heart of Sebastian, Wasabi Thai Sushi is where East meets West in a symphony of flavors. Renowned for their spicy tuna roll that will send your senses sailing, they offer a palette of dishes that soothingly blend the delicate art of sushi with the hearty essence of Thai cooking. 

Don’t miss the Mas-sa-man curry (avocado, sweet potato, onion, peanuts, and your choice of protein) or their celebrated sushi boat — a treasure trove for any sushi lover!

massaman-curry-dish-sebastian

Want to Stay Overnight?

You may love Sebastian so much that you choose to make it an overnight. Island View Cottages, on 11450 S Indian River Drive, offer individually decorated and fashionable cottages that are second to none. You’ll love the artistic design and the serene scenery that envelops this beautiful Florida lodging complex. They even provide complimentary kayaks and have hammocks for relaxing in the sun with a good book or for a nap.

Cottages 3, 4, and 11 are my favorites. You can view each one online and see for yourself which fits your style and budget.

island-view-sebastian-lodging

In Sebastian, Florida, every meal expresses place and tradition, with chefs as passionate about their craft as their community. Whether you’re in the mood for fresh, briny seafood or craving some local brew, you’ll find that these cherished eateries don’t just serve food; they serve up experiences.

Read more of our Florida posts:

Best Things to Do in Vero Beach

Fun Things to Do in Naples

Culinary Adventures of DeLand

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.