Sebring, Florida, may be known for its historic raceway, but it’s also home to some extraordinary dining spots. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, these five restaurants promise to captivate your taste buds. Let’s explore what makes these local places to eat in Sebring special and why they deserve a spot on your must-visit list!
Cowpoke’s Watering Hole
Cowpoke’s Watering Hole is a massive venue with 295 seats, yet it feels cozy and inviting thanks to its separate dining rooms, tiki bar, and frequent live entertainment. It’s where you can savor good food while enjoying line dancing or karaoke.
What to Savor
Begin your meal with their flavorful Fried Green Tomatoes or Bacon-Wrapped Asparagus. Cowpoke’s is renowned for its Choice Chairman’s Reserve Certified Premium Beef steaks, but don’t miss out on their pasta, chicken, and fish tacos.
I thoroughly enjoyed their perfectly cooked steak with sautéed mushrooms and onions. For dessert, the Florida Orange Cake is a must-try, leaving a delightful burst of citrusy goodness.
Nutmeg’s Cafe
Nutmeg’s Cafe is a charming combination of a gourmet bakery, coffee shop, and sandwich haven. I had been eyeing their delicious offerings on social media long before my visit, and they did not disappoint.
What to Savor
The Mousetrap is a creative masterpiece, Nutmeg’s signature panini, with five kinds of cheese, spices, and artichoke hearts. Pair it with the nostalgic English Pea Salad for a delightful meal.
The pea salad garnered so many comments on social media, reminding me how much I loved this classic dish from the past.
Buddha bowls are also big sellers. Take home some gourmet cookies, cupcakes, and macarons from the bakery to treat yourself later.
Two hours from Sebring is Dunedin, which would be a perfect place to add another day of fun on your Florida adventure.
Chicanes Restaurant
Located within the stylish Inn on the Lakes Hotel, Chicanes Restaurant offers both lunch and dinner in an elegant yet relaxed setting. Whether you’re in the mood for a casual lunch or a fancy dinner, Chicanes has you covered.
What to Savor
For lunch, their burgers and club sandwiches are excellent choices, especially when paired with their truffle fries. Chicanes French Onion Soup and Caesar salad are also top-notch.
Dinner is where Chicanes truly shines. The Rollovers, bite-sized filet mignon twisted around pepper jack cheese, are divine, but the cedar plank salmon with mashed potatoes and garlicky green beans is a stellar choice.
Faded Bistro and Beer Garden
Faded Bistro and Beer Garden offers a unique dining experience with both indoor and outdoor seating surrounded by lush gardens. The ambiance alone is enough to draw you in, but the food will keep you coming back.
What to Savor
Start with the Charcuterie and Cheese Board, filled with cured meats, artisanal cheeses, olives, honey, spreads, and pickled vegetables. The Irish Nachos with stout beer cheese, bacon, and green onions are another crowd favorite.
Remember to check out their weekend brunch offerings and craft cocktails.
My husband’s favorite thing about Faded Bistro was the Sweet Habanero Mezcalita, a delightful mix of Sombra Mezcal, Ole Smokey Mango Habanero Whiskey, muddled sweet pepper, and fresh sour mix.
Jaxson’s on the Lake
A short drive from Sebring, in Lake Placid, you’ll find Jaxson’s, a beloved local restaurant known for its addictive Hookiemelt. This long-running establishment is well worth the visit.
What to Savor
The famous Hookiemelt is a must-try. Choose your style of chicken (fried, blackened, or grilled), served on a bed of sour cream, onions, cheese, and wing sauce, then baked until ooey-gooey and served with tortilla chips.
Be warned—it’s incredibly addictive!
Come on Thursdays for Karaoke nights.
Making the Most of Your Culinary Adventure
Sebring’s dining scene is diverse and exciting, offering everything from hearty steaks to gourmet sandwiches. These five exceptional places bring something unique to the table, promising unforgettable meals and warm, welcoming atmospheres.
Thanks to Visit Sebring and Inn on the Lakes for hosting my visit, accommodations, and meals. As always, opinions and reviews are 100% mine and unbiased.
Check out more of our Florida posts: